Is It Still Okay To Promote Someone Without Increasing Their Salary?
Updated: Dec 14, 2020
Welcome to my weekly Q&A roundup. (Scroll down to find the Q&A.)
If this is your first time here, welcome. I spend a fair amount of time speaking at events and conferences. At the end of my presentations, I leave space for audience members to ask questions—tough questions, brave questions, you name it.
The level of candor and curiosity always inspires me, and I want to share that sentiment with you. So each week, I pick one question that I believe others would find most instructive and publish my response to it here.
The purpose of this weekly tradition is transparency and inclusivity.
• Transparency: a behind-the-scenes look at my day-to-day.
• Inclusivity: bringing others along in the journey.
Consideration To Take When Awarding a Promotion Without a Raise
Can I (ethically/legally) give an employee a promotion without a raise? There’s a backstory. At the end of 2019, I promoted a male employee and increased his pay. Now I’d like to promote a female employee, but since COVID hit my department doesn’t have the budget to increase her pay.
Yes, you can legally promote an employee (female, male, or other) without giving them a pay raise. However, you have to provide legitimate reasoning for doing so. And what counts as “legitimate” depends on where your business is located. Pay attention.
As a starting point, federal law—as enforced by the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission—prohibits employers from using the following criteria to justify promotion or pay differentials among employees:
Sex (including pregnancy, sexual orientation, and gender identity)
Age (40 or older)
After considering federal law, you also need to look into your state and local laws. For example, if your company resides in Colorado, then the Equal Pay for Equal Work Act will limit the set of conditions you could use to justify sex-based pay differentials to the following:
Quantity or quality of production
Education, training, or experience reasonably related to the work in question
Those are the legal considerations. Next, let’s talk about the ethical considerations of giving a raise-less promotion.
The Normalization of Raise-less Promotions
Promotions without a pay raise have increasingly become the norm.
Between 2011 and 2018, the percentage of HR managers who say it’s common for their organization to promote employees without raising their salaries jumped from 22% to 39%. Only 20% of HR managers say they don’t offer promotions without a raise.
On the other side of the table, a full 64% of employees* say they would be willing to accept a promotion even if it didn't include a raise. That makes sense.
Promotions keep employees engaged. They challenge employees with new projects, responsibilities, and strategies. They reward employees for a job well done. They boost resumes and increase prospects in the job market.
But the value of raise-less promotion only goes so far. Without financial compensation for assuming more responsibility, alignment between workload and pay strays.
This divergence sends a message to employees that they are not valued equitably. Or that the worth they bring to the organization is negligible.
Because women’s work has been systematically devalued and under-compensated for centuries, companies must ensure they do not aggravate matters of equity when it comes time to promote and pay their employees.
How COVID-19 Changes the Promotion Conversation
COVID-19 has wreaked havoc on businesses around the world. This has led to widespread layoffs, furloughs, and hiring/salary freezes. It sounds like your department is under similar constraints.
So if COVID-related budget cuts are keeping you from increasing an employee’s salary after awarding her a promotion, then be sure to follow these three parameters:
Clearly and empathetically communicate (verbally and in writing) why the promotion is not attached to a pay raise.
Establish a timeline (and put it in writing) to revisit a pay raise in the next three to six months.
Explore alternative compensation options. Note: such alternatives are not meant to replace a future pay raise but rather to show the employee that you value their increased contributions to the team.
*64% is the aggregate percentage of employees who reported willingness to take a promotion without a salary increase. When disaggregated by gender, that becomes 72% of men and 55% of women. Unfortunately, we don’t have race/ethnicity information to further disaggregate the data. We also don’t have data to understand why more men versus women say they would accept a promotion without a pay raise.
These Q&A roundups can be delivered directly to you—a week before I publish them here.
(All you need is an email address.)